Well hello readers.
Here’s my first in a series of weekly album reviews.
I like music, and I know music. And I have the one things a reviewer needs. A strong opinion.
I’ll go through the history of the album and the artist, than every song on the album. I’ll tell you everything you want to know about the song and give each song a 1-100 grade, and the entire album a 1-100 grade, and a letter grade. (Thorough right?)
History:
I’ll start with my favorite artist and my favorite album.
Notes From Elsewhere (2007)
Peter Mulvey is an American singer-songwriter based in Milwaukee Wisconsin. He’s attended Marquette University where he started his music career. He traveled to Dublin where he preformed for a short while and spent several years in Boston where he was known to preform in the cities subway system. He has released 15 albums, been featured on four compilations and put been featured in two DVD’(one solo, one compilation).
Notes From Elsewhere released Nov 6, 2007 was an ‘acoustic retrospective album’ and petermulvey.com says that it “…is a retrospective collection of the very best songs he(Peter) has written and performed over his 15 year recording career. Recorded solo in a studio, with just an acoustic guitar, these are fresh takes on songs that have become fan and critic favorites over the years. While his previous band-backed albums showcased the songs, these solo versions allow each song to shine on its own demonstrating Peter’s strengths as a songwriter.” It received 3.5 stars from allmusic.com
Songs:
For Notes From Elsewhere was recorded mostly solo and brought in the accompaniment of David Goodrich and for one track Paul Cebar. these tracks one asterisk for David Goodrich and Two asterisks for where both Goodrich and Cebar were accompanying. The songs on the album are as so. The album runs 59 minutes and 03 seconds.
1. Shirt* – 3:32
2. Better Way to Go – 3:42
3. The Dreams – 1:50
4. Old Simon Stimson – 2:57
5. Rapture – 4:03
6. The Trouble with Poets* – 3:32
7. Grace* – 3:27
8. Black Rabbit – 3:10
9. If Love Is Not Enough – 4:07
10. The Knuckleball Suite – 3:35
11. Every Word Except Goodbye* – 3:57
12. Charlie** – 3:38
13. Tender Blindspot – 4:05
14. On the Way Up – 3:49
15. Wings of the Ragman* – 3:33
16. Words Too Small to Say* – 3:47
17. Little Foot – 1:29
Review:
1. Shirt: 84 points
To put this song first on the album was a great idea. It’s not the best on the album but it’s damn good. It right away establishes Peter’s great Guitar playing. You’re also introduced to his amazing lyrics. This was the first Peter Mulvey song that I’ve ever heard him sing and I was blown away. (I heard “On the Way Up” from my father on the guitar.) A very good song all around.
2. Better Way to Go: 57 points
I’ve found a pattern with the second song on many albums, it’s a good song, it’s not a great song, it’s got a few good components and it’s worth listening to, but not by a lot. “Better Way to Go” seems to fit this criteria perfectly. Peter’s guitar playing doesn’t seem to fall right up my alley and the lyrics are good, but that’s after the first few verses. Even though it is a weak song on its own; it’s placement in the album works out well. I always listen to it.
3:The Dreams 93 points
“The Dreams” is my second favorite song on the album. When I first listened to this song his singing hit me. Peter Mulvey has more of a talking voice than a singing voice. He does sing, but you know when he switches to talking. (I’ll never post boring complete verses of songs, but here is the link to the lyrics for this song). Seriously worth looking at, beautiful poetry.
4.Old Simon Stimson: 80 points
“Old Simon Stimson” is one of only two songs that I recognize from previous albums. (The only other album I have is his The Knuckleball Suite.) To compare the two would be a disservice to the song(songs?). I’m not too partial to the electric guitar in his version on The Knuckleball Suite, but that’s another topic. Old Simon Stimson is a very good song for any occasion I’d say.
5. Rapture: 92 points
“Rapture” is a great song, it starts out with low note to get you in a certain state of mood, and it play’s around with that. It’s definitely one of the darker sounding songs but also one of my favorites. I haven’t heard his version of the song from the original album “Rapture (1995)” But it is next on my list of albums to buy. It is a moody piece that I’m always happy to listen to.
6.The Trouble with Poets: 79 points
I like to laugh at the irony in “The Trouble with Poets.” Being a poet (and a beautifully gifted one at that) his argument seems to carry no weight. But at the same time I like to agree with his message. I’m no fan of the written poetry but however I’m a large literature fan as well as a large music fan. Being three different expressions from the same root I always like to listen to the poetic words of this song and smile. It doesn’t make sense but hey. “Sometimes nobody knows, nobody knows. Not even poets know…”
7. Grace: 84 points
I really like Grace for both its lyrics and its music but I don’t know how it moves me. It fits right in with the mood of “Rapture” and the lyrics all seem to make sort of sense but I just can’t get myself to understand it. I was originally going to give it 76 points but I decided that it deserved more. It’s such a great piece of music that I can deal with the fact that It seemingly makes no sense to me.
8. Black Rabbit: 89 points
“Black Rabbit” is an amazing acoustic piece. There are no lyrics so there isn’t much to be said about it. However, there is a YouTube video of Peter playing “Black Rabbit” here. It’s amazing to see him play.( Peter has even commented on the video from time to time.)
9. If Love is not enough: 82 points
I like the lyrics of this song espescialy, at this point in the album his guitar playing is still great but it just needs a lyrical song to kick the energy back. This is it, He keeps talking about a bad relationship saying “if love is not enough than what’s enough?” It sounds like he’s asking her until the last line. “If love is not enough, we will go on loving anyway. We are stubborn that way.” It’s a great song.
10. The Knuckleball Suite: 80
I enjoy this song as a nice cool down song, (like most of Peter’s songs seem to be.) And I know I said to compare any one of his songs to his other versions of The song would be a disservice, but I lied and I believe that This version is better than his original version. Call it a personal preference but the mood that Notes From Elsewhere has taken the song is better in my opinion.
11. Every Word Except Goodbye: 73 points
This is a good song, even as a stand alone song, but compared to the other songs on the album it seems to lose favor, and that’s probably why it is in 11th place on the album. A calm, beautiful song, but lacking in some way, (and I don’t know how it’s lacking at all but I can feel that it is.)
12. Charlie: 96 points
At number 12 on the list it is unusual to find such a great song as Charlie, where most albums these days have faded energy, or ended completely by 12 tracks. peter throws in one of my favorite songs on this album. Winning 96 points in my review it was also the chosen featured song on petermulvey.com to represent the album. (Direct link to the music : Charlie)
13. Tender Blindspot: 89 points
I love the beginning of this song.
“It’s Cold, but at least the sun is out.”
Those words hit hard like a sledgehammer,(Peter Gabriel Review to come later!) and the lyrics and music continue to work in perfect harmony for the rest of the song. It’s just an amazing song.
14. On The Way Up: 81 points
My father learned this song on the guitar from either Rapture (1995) or Goodbye Bob (1997). And I think he and I are in consensus when I say that This was not as good as the version that my father learned from. On The Way Up has great sentimental value for me, and maybe that’s why I don’t enjoy it as much on this album but It’s some good guitar playing.
15. Wings of the Ragman: 92 points
Another great song, equal in energy, mood, playing and lyrics to “Charlie” or “Rapture” The beginnings of his songs always have the greatest hits compared to other artists and this is no exception with plenty of delicious low notes and “The woman beside you, her shoulders are smoking, her eyes fill up with flame.” Brilliant lyrics. This song always gives me a good feeling and has inspired me to name a picture after it. The picture isn’t the greatest quality now that I look at it, but I like it just the same.
16. Words Too Small to Say: 80 points
I’m looking at the score’s I’ve given these songs and I’m really having a hard time giving anything less than an 80 (with the exception of “Better Way to Go”) I just love this whole album and although Words Too Small to Say falls into the category of weaker songs on the album. the half spoken word, half singing, half poem, half song gets to me. The words ebb and flow with the song. I wish I knew what was going on in Peter’s head while he plays this.
17. Little Foot: 100 Points
I’m giving this song a full 100 points. It is my favorite song on the album and one of my favorite songs ever. I can’t say enough about this song It’s only about 1 minute and 30 seconds long, but I can listen to it on repeat forever. Before I changed computers my itunes clocked it at having over 2000 plays, (I’m only at 170 right now but it’s going up as I type this.) I play this song whenever. If I’m feeling happy, if I’m feeling sad, While I’m working at stage crew, if I’m sitting and writing at my computer.
I remember that last summer I spent a week in a Zen Buddhist Monastery in New York, at the base of the Catskills. I wasn’t allowed to have my electronics turned on for the whole week, but as I sat in the bus I turned on my iPod to listen to this song. I can’t express enough love for this song. I will turn on this album, and as I get to the end, set this song on an endless repeat. Call me crazy but I love this song. I can’t wait to hear it on Peter’s “Brother Rabbit Speaks/Rain” album (2001).
Final Review: A+
I give this song a 97 points out of 100. I still haven’t found that perfect album but this one comes damn close. The songs are all recorded in top quality, the placement of the tracks from 1-17 is logical and pleasing and gets me in a happy, yet pensive, mature, and somewhat dark mood. Peter’s great songwriting and guitar playing is apparent from the beginning to end.
I can’t wait until I see him play in person.
My Picture: Wings of the Ragman
P.S
If You want me to review any album, I will gladly do so. Just comment on any review that I’ve put up and I’ll gladly listen to and review for you any music you’d like, (Although I will probably rate rap and hip-hop pretty low.) I will be posting new reviews Every Thursday